
Austin Proper Hotel
Best for city access, multiple on-site dining options, and full spa & fitness services.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Austin Proper Hotel is a five-star downtown Austin hotel with designer interiors, multiple restaurants, a rooftop pool, and an on-site spa—best for travelers who want central access to music, dining, and wellness amenities. Secluded Guest House in Beautiful Setting is a small, quiet vacation house on Slaughter Creek Drive, aimed at travelers looking for an affordable, private stay outside central Austin.
Updated · about 12.8 mi (20.6 km) apart

Best for city access, multiple on-site dining options, and full spa & fitness services.

Best for budget-conscious travelers or small groups wanting a quiet, private house with free on-site parking and a garden.
When Austin Proper Hotel wins: Choose Austin Proper if you want central, walkable access to Austin’s live-music and dining scene, multiple on-site restaurants and bars, a staffed full-service spa (Verbena Spa), a rooftop pool, and extensive fitness and event facilities.
When Secluded Guest House in Beautiful Setting wins: Choose the Secluded Guest House if you need a simple, standalone house with free self parking and basic Wi‑Fi in a quieter South Austin neighborhood, and you’re planning to spend more time driving around Austin than staying in a downtown hotel.
Bottom line: Austin Proper is a full-service, design-forward downtown hotel for guests prioritizing amenities, restaurants, and walkable location; the Secluded Guest House is a low-key, lower-star house outside central Austin for travelers prioritizing privacy and parking over on-site services.
| Category | Austin Proper Hotel | Secluded Guest House in Beautiful Setting |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Five-star, design-forward downtown hotel with many on-site services | Quiet, simple private guest house outside central Austin |
| Location | Second Street District, Downtown Austin (walkable to Lady Bird Lake and 6th Street) | Slaughter Creek Acres area, South Austin (residential; requires driving to downtown) |
| Size | 238 guest rooms and suites (+ 99 branded residences) | Not published |
| Star rating / guest rating | 5 stars | 2 stars (user rating not listed) |
| Room types listed | 13 room and suite types (Deluxe Suite, Grand Room, Premier Suite, Proper Penthouse, etc.) | House |
| Pools / signature amenity | Rooftop pool and sun deck on 5th floor (guest access; reservable cabanas) | No pool listed; garden on property |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues (The Peacock, La Piscina, Goldie's, The Quill Room, Kappo Kappo) | No on-site restaurant listed |
| Spa & wellness | Verbena Spa (treatments, Recovery Room, steam room) and 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Parking | On-site valet parking (fee) and EV charging | Free self parking and onsite garage |
| Accessibility & Wi‑Fi | Premium Wi‑Fi (amenity fee), accessible pool and other facilities | Free WiFi; wheelchair-accessible parking listed (property notes 'Wheelchair accessible – no' ambiguous for some spaces) |
Austin Proper sits in the Second Street District, a walkable downtown spot steps from Lady Bird Lake and music venues.
Best for travelers who want to stay in the center of Austin’s activity and cut down on driving.
The Secluded Guest House is in the Slaughter Creek Acres neighborhood of South Austin, a residential area away from downtown bustle.
Better for travelers who prefer a quieter, residential base and don’t need immediate downtown access.
Austin Proper offers 238 guest rooms and suites across 13 named room types with designer touches.
Choose Austin Proper if you want a range of room types and suite perks with professionally serviced rooms.
Secluded Guest House is listed as a single house rental rather than multiple hotel rooms.
The guest house is a straightforward, single-unit option—good for guests who prefer private house stays but expect fewer on-site services.
Austin Proper has several dedicated restaurants and bars on the property for breakfast, lunch, dinner, and cocktails.
Austin Proper is the clear choice for guests who want multiple on-site dining and late-night lounge options.
The supplier listing for Secluded Guest House does not list any on-site restaurants or bars.
Expect to rely on nearby neighborhood or downtown restaurants rather than on-site dining.
Austin Proper operates a fifth-floor rooftop pool and sun deck for registered guests and Proper Club members.
If a hotel pool and a rooftop social scene matter, Austin Proper offers an on-site option integrated with food and drink service.
Secluded Guest House lists a garden as an outdoor feature but does not list a pool.
The guest house is suitable for guests who value private outdoor space rather than hotel-style pool facilities.
Austin Proper includes Verbena Spa, a Recovery Room, and a 24-hour fitness center with extensive equipment and classes.
Pick Austin Proper if you want on-site spa and fitness offerings plus an easy path to Austin nightlife.
Secluded Guest House does not list a spa or fitness facilities in its supplier listing.
Expect to go off-property for spa, gym, or nightlife options from the guest house.

Austin Proper — walkable to 6th Street, ACL Live, and downtown venues with on-site lounge music nights.

Secluded Guest House — a private house in a residential area with free self parking and a garden.

Austin Proper — multiple restaurants and bars on property covering Mediterranean, coastal Mexican, cocktails, and kappo.

Secluded Guest House — simple 2-star house rental for travelers who prioritize price and a low-key stay over hotel services.
Austin Proper — it’s centrally located in the Second Street District within walking distance of many downtown attractions.
Secluded Guest House — the supplier listing explicitly notes free self parking onsite; Austin Proper relies on paid valet parking.
No — Austin Proper has a rooftop pool and a full spa (Verbena Spa). The Secluded Guest House lists a garden but does not list a pool or spa.
No — both properties are listed as all-ages; Austin Proper is family-friendly though it leans adult-friendly in atmosphere.
Explore how Austin Proper Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·