
Austin Proper Hotel
Best for being in the heart of downtown Austin with easy walking access to live music, restaurants, and Lady Bird Lake.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Austin Proper Hotel is a downtown, design-forward five-star hotel with rooftop pool, multiple destination restaurants, and an on-site Verbena Spa—best for travelers who want a central base near Austin’s music, dining, and waterfront paths. Commodore Perry Estate, Auberge Collection is an ultra-luxury estate-style hotel in a residential/near-campus area of Austin—readers considering a quieter, estate-like luxury stay with Auberge service should compare it here.
Updated

Best for being in the heart of downtown Austin with easy walking access to live music, restaurants, and Lady Bird Lake.

Best for travelers who prefer an estate-style, ultra-luxury hotel experience outside the central entertainment strip.
When Austin Proper Hotel wins: choose Austin Proper if you want to be in the Second Street / downtown entertainment district, prioritize rooftop pool time, multiple on-site dining options, and a large spa and fitness program tied to a 24/7 gym and recovery room.
When Commodore Perry Estate, Auberge Collection wins: choose Commodore Perry Estate if you prefer an estate-style property with Auberge Collection positioning, a quieter neighborhood near the University of Texas area, and an intimate, garden-and-suite hotel layout.
Bottom line: Austin Proper is the pick for downtown convenience, varied restaurants, and active wellness amenities; Commodore Perry Estate is the alternative for travelers seeking an estate-like, luxury boutique stay under the Auberge flag. Pick based on whether you want downtown energy (Proper) or a quieter estate setting (Commodore Perry).
| Category | Austin Proper Hotel | Commodore Perry Estate, Auberge Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Design-forward urban luxury, energetic downtown setting | Ultra-luxury estate-style, residential/near-campus setting |
| Location | 600 W 2nd Street — Second Street District, walkable to Lady Bird Lake and music venues | 4100 Red River St — estate-style neighborhood near UT and Hancock area |
| Size | 238 rooms + 99 branded residences | Not published |
| Ages / family policy | All ages welcome; property leans adult-friendly | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Rooftop pool and sun deck on the 5th floor; guest-only access, reservable cabanas | Outdoor swimming pool(s) listed; estate pool access and accessibility features noted |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple outlets (The Peacock, La Piscina, Goldie's, The Quill Room, Kappo Kappo) | On-site restaurants and bar(s) listed; signature outlets not published |
| Spa & wellness | Verbena Spa (4th floor) with treatment rooms, Recovery Room, steam room, 24/7 fitness center | Spa/fitness services not published in supplier listing |
| Known for | Rooftop pool, Kelly Wearstler design, downtown location, Verbena Spa | Auberge Collection service and estate-style property |
| Accessibility & pet policy | Pet-friendly (dogs up to 45 lbs for a fee); smoke-free; accessible pool features noted | Wheelchair accessible, roll-in showers, pet-friendly with on-site pet bowls |
| Parking & transport | On-site valet parking (fee); complimentary city bike rentals included in amenity fee | On-site car park and valet parking listed; shuttle service noted |
Austin Proper sits in Downtown Austin’s Second Street District, steps from Lady Bird Lake and music venues.
Pick Austin Proper if you want immediate downtown access and walkability to Austin’s attractions.
Commodore Perry Estate is an Auberge Collection property located on Red River Street near the Hancock/UT area.
Choose Commodore Perry Estate if you prefer a quieter, estate-style location that’s close to the UT/Hancock area rather than the downtown nightlife strip.
Austin Proper offers 238 guest rooms and suites with Kelly Wearstler–designed interiors and suite-level perks.
Austin Proper suits travelers who want a wide range of modern luxury room options in downtown Austin.
Commodore Perry Estate lists a mix of rooms and several named suites indicative of estate accommodations.
Commodore Perry Estate is appropriate for travelers seeking classic estate-style suites and accessible room options.
Austin Proper features several on-site restaurants and bars spanning Mediterranean, coastal Mexican, Japanese-French, and cocktail lounges.
Austin Proper is for travelers who want varied on-site dining choices without leaving the hotel.
Commodore Perry Estate lists restaurants and bars as property amenities, reflecting on-site dining for guests.
Commodore Perry Estate should suit guests who prefer intimate on-site dining in an estate setting; check the property for current menus and outlet names.
Austin Proper’s signature amenity is its 5th-floor rooftop pool and sun deck with cabanas and poolside dining.
If a rooftop pool with skyline views is important, Austin Proper is the clearer choice.
Commodore Perry Estate lists outdoor swimming pool(s) among its amenities, consistent with an estate-style property.
Commodore Perry Estate provides estate-style pool facilities with strong accessibility features; contact the hotel for pool location and guest policies.
Austin Proper emphasizes wellness with Verbena Spa, a Recovery Room, and a fully equipped 24/7 fitness center.
Austin Proper is best for travelers who want a robust on-site wellness program plus easy access to downtown nightlife and live music.
Commodore Perry Estate’s supplier listing highlights garden spaces and hotel bars/restaurants but does not publish a named spa or nightlife venues.
Commodore Perry Estate offers a quieter evening environment and estate amenities; confirm spa and wellness offerings directly with the hotel.

Austin Proper — steps from Lady Bird Lake, live-music venues, and downtown restaurants.

Commodore Perry Estate — Auberge Collection positioning and estate-layout suites for a quieter luxury stay.

Austin Proper — multiple distinct restaurants and bars, including rooftop and kappo dining.

Commodore Perry Estate — supplier listing highlights roll-in showers, sloped pool entries, and self-operating pool lifts.
Austin Proper. It’s located in the Second Street District with short walks to live-music venues, restaurants, and Lady Bird Lake.
Commodore Perry Estate. The Auberge Collection positioning and estate-style room names indicate a quieter, more residential-feeling property.
Austin Proper’s rooftop pool is reserved for registered hotel guests and Proper Club members. Commodore Perry Estate lists pools in its amenities; check the property for any guest-access rules.
Austin Proper has a named Verbena Spa with a Recovery Room and extensive fitness equipment; Commodore Perry’s supplier listing does not publish a named spa, so contact the hotel for details.
Explore how Austin Proper Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·